Honest Comparison · Updated March 2026

TradeZella grades the trade after it closes.
We flag the leak while it's still open.

TradeZella is a post-mortem, you study what went wrong after the account already took the hit. RB Trading reviews every trade with AI, names the setups quietly draining you, and shows your prop drawdown room in real time, before you place the trade. Same analytics, plus the live edge they don't have, for $29.99/month with a 30-day money-back guarantee. TradeZella is $35–$99/mo with no money-back guarantee.

Start Free → See Full Comparison

30-day money-back guarantee · Full access from day one · Cancel anytime

See It In Action

They show you the past. We show you the present, for a third of the price.

Profit factor, expectancy, monthly P&L and R-multiple distribution, all included from day one.

The short version: TradeZella is a good product with a beautiful UI. But at $59/month on Pro with no way to try it first and no money-back guarantee, you're making a $708/year commitment on faith. RB Trading Pro Journal gives you every core feature, full analytics, prop firm tracker, emotion tagging, calendar, risk manager, AI plain-English backtesting and bar-by-bar replay, at $29.99/month, fully refundable for 30 days. If you're a prop firm trader watching your costs, this comparison is worth 2 minutes of your time.
The Problem With TradeZella

Three reasons traders switch

No free trial. No money-back guarantee.
TradeZella has no free tier and advertises no money-back guarantee. You pay before you log a single trade.
$59/month is $708/year
At $59/month you're spending more on your journal than most traders spend on their entire trading toolkit. For funded traders who are already paying evaluation fees, that's a real cost. RB Trading is $29.99/month, you save $348 a year.
Core features locked behind Premium
Trade replay, TradeZella's headline feature, is not on the entry tier. The Essential plan at $35/month gives you a limited experience. You're pushed toward the $59 plan to get full value. With RB Trading, everything is included from day one.
Feature by Feature

Full comparison

Every feature that matters for a prop firm trader, side by side.

RB Trading Pro Journal TradeZella
Monthly price$29.99/mo$35–$99/mo
Annual price$299/yr$315–$891/yr
Risk-free period 30-day money-back None
Refund policy Full refund within 30 days No money-back guarantee
Trade journal Included Included
Performance analytics 100+ metrics 50+ reports
Prop firm tracker All major firms Supported
Daily drawdown tracker Live alerts Available
Emotion / psychology tags Per-trade tagging Available
P&L Calendar Month/week/day Available
Risk calculator Live FX rates, all markets Available
AI backtesting (plain English) All plans, untestable rules flagged Available
Saved strategies & deep history tests Included Available
CSV import (MT4, MT5, FTMO) 14 platforms Supported
Multi-account support Unlimited 1 account (Basic)
Trade replay (bar-by-bar) Included all plans Pro only ($59)
RB Score (performance grade) Unique feature Not available
Daily trade planner Pre/post market Not available
Data stays on your device Local storage, private Cloud only
Works in any browser No install needed Web-based
Price Breakdown

The cost difference adds up fast

RB Trading Pro Journal
$29.99
per month · $299/year
30-Day Money-Back Guarantee
  • Live floating P&L on open trades (TradeZella has none)
  • Auto-sync from MT4/MT5/cTrader/DXtrade
  • Full access from day one
  • All features, no tiers
  • Multi-account, unlimited
  • Cancel anytime
  • You save $348/year vs TradeZella Pro
TradeZella Pro
$59
per month · $531/year
No Free Trial
  • No free trial, pay first
  • No money-back guarantee
  • Trade replay is Pro and up
  • 1 account on Basic plan
  • $708/year billed monthly, no money-back guarantee
Why Traders Switch

What switching actually gets you

The same core toolkit, prop tracker, emotion tags, full analytics, at a fraction of what most journals charge. Every price is on this page before you sign up for anything.
Straight pricing
$29.99/mo (99¢ a day) or $299/yr (82¢ a day)
Every Pro plan carries a 30-day money-back guarantee. If the journal does not show you something about your trading you did not already know, one email gets a full refund.
30-day guarantee
No forms, no questions
Start on the free plan: 50 trades with live MT4/MT5 auto-sync included, forex, stocks, crypto and indices, no card, no clock. Judge it on your own trades before paying a penny.
Free to judge
50 trades free, sync included
In Their Words

What Journal users tell us

“Auto-sync from MT5 means I don't have to log anything by hand. After a couple of weeks the analytics showed my worst setup and the session that was quietly killing me. Fixed both and the account started behaving.”
Lukas M.Germany · Journal user
“The AI review pointed out I was cutting winners early and letting losers run. Sounds obvious, but seeing it on my own trades made it stick. Expectancy flipped positive.”
Chloe S.United Kingdom · Journal user
“I used to revenge trade after a stop-out. The journal priced exactly what that habit was costing me. Once I stopped, the equity curve smoothed out and I passed the next phase.”
Ananya D.India · Journal user
Ready to switch?

30-day money-back guarantee.
No card. No commitment.

Full access from day one. If it's not right for you, walk away with a full refund.

Start Free →

$29.99/mo (99¢ a day) · Cancel anytime

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

How much does TradeZella cost?

TradeZella costs $59 per month on its Pro plan, with no free trial and no money-back guarantee. RB Trading Pro Journal offers comparable analytics, a prop firm drawdown tracker and emotion tagging for $29.99 per month with a 30-day money-back guarantee.

Is there a cheaper alternative to TradeZella?

Yes. RB Trading Pro Journal ($29.99/mo or $299/yr) covers the same core features: full trade analytics, R-multiple tracking, backtesting and replay, AI trade reviews, emotion tracking and a live prop firm challenge tracker for FTMO, FunderPro, E8, Apex and The5ers. It is browser-based with no install, and every plan carries a 30-day money-back guarantee.

Does TradeZella offer refunds?

TradeZella does not advertise a money-back guarantee, and we found no published refund policy. RB Trading Pro Journal includes a 30-day money-back guarantee on every plan: full access from day one, and a full refund by email within 30 days if it is not for you.