Trading journal

How to review trades: a 5-minute daily and 30-minute weekly review

Nathan · RB Trading Updated 9 Nov 2026 8 min read
An open notebook with pens and glasses, with the title How to review your trades
Photo: Shixart1985, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

To review trades, judge the process before the profit. Every day, spend 5 minutes giving each trade its R result and a yes or no for "followed plan?". Every week, spend 30 minutes ranking setups by total R, adding up the R lost on rule breaks and choosing one rule to change. Below is a filled example week.

This guide covers the daily 5-minute review and the weekly 30-minute review as numbered steps, a weekly review filled in on example numbers, a copy-and-paste trade review template, a checklist and the questions to ask about every losing trade.

What does a trade review actually check?

Two things, and only two: did you follow your plan, and what did each setup earn in R. Dollar P&L changes with position size, so it hides whether your decisions got better. R does not. A trade that risked $200 and made $400 is +2R, at any account size. If R is new to you, start with R-multiples explained or the short R-multiple definition, and use the R-multiple calculator for any trade you have not scored yet.

A review only works on a record. If you do not log trades yet, set that up first with our guide to how to journal trades, then come back.

The daily 5-minute review, step by step

Do it straight after your session, while you still remember why you took each trade.

  1. Open today's trades, sorted by time.
  2. Check every trade has its R result. Result divided by the planned risk. Fill any gaps now, not on Sunday.
  3. Mark "followed plan?" yes or no for each one. No essays, one word.
  4. Tag each "no" with one mistake from a fixed list: early entry, moved stop, oversized, no setup, revenge.
  5. Write one line for tomorrow: one thing to repeat and one thing to drop.

That is the whole daily review. Do not judge setups on one day of trades. The daily job is to make the record complete and honest, so the weekly review has something true to work with.

The weekly 30-minute review, step by step

Pick a fixed time when markets are shut, such as Saturday morning or Sunday evening.

  1. Pull the week's trades into one list, by setup. (5 minutes)
  2. Write the headline numbers: trades, total R, win rate, average win and average loss in R. (5 minutes)
  3. Rank setups by total R, best to worst, with the average R per trade beside each. (5 minutes)
  4. Add up the R lost where "followed plan?" is no, and list what broke the plan each time. (5 minutes)
  5. Replay the biggest win and the biggest loss. Note how far price went against you (MAE) and in your favour (MFE). (5 minutes)
  6. Write one rule change for next week, and how you will check it next Sunday. (5 minutes)

One change, not five. If you change five things at once, next week's numbers cannot tell you which one worked.

A filled weekly review: the example week

Example week. Every number below is made up and rounded to show the method. These are not real trades, real results or trade calls.

The trader takes 20 trades over five days, each with a planned risk of 1R, across four setups. The week ends at +3R, with 8 wins from 20 trades, a 40% win rate.

Step 1: setups ranked by total R

RankSetupTradesWinsLossesTotal RAverage R a trade
1Pullback844+4R+0.5R
2Range fade422+2R+0.5R
3Breakout624-1R-0.17R
4News202-2R-1R
Week20812+3R+0.15R

Every win in this example is +2R. Every loss is -1R except one breakout loss of -2R. On these numbers, breakout looks like the setup to drop. Step 2 says otherwise.

Step 2: the R lost where "followed plan?" = no

TradeSetupWhat broke the planResult
Tuesday, trade 3BreakoutMoved the stop further away-2R
Wednesday, trade 2BreakoutEntered before the candle closed-1R
Thursday, trade 1NewsNot a setup in the plan-1R
Friday, trade 4NewsNot a setup in the plan-1R
Total4 trades-5R

So the breakout setup is not the problem. The rule breaks inside it are. A review that stops at Step 1 would have dropped a setup that works.

Step 3: one rule change for next week

Pick the change that would have saved the most R and is easy to check. Here two causes tie at 2R each: the news trades and the moved stop. The trader picks the stop rule, because it touches every setup. The news trades become next week's candidate if they happen again.

Rule change for next week

Like a review that puts risk first? So does the free weekly letter, built on the 3-Gate method. Get the free letter

Trade review template (copy and paste)

Paste this into a note or a spreadsheet. The daily half takes 5 minutes, the weekly half takes 30. If you want a full trade log to sit under it, our trading log template has the columns.

DAILY REVIEW (5 minutes)                 Date: ________
Trade | Setup | Result (R) | Followed plan? | Mistake tag | Note
1     |       |            | yes / no       |             |
2     |       |            | yes / no       |             |
Tomorrow, repeat: ________   Tomorrow, drop: ________

WEEKLY REVIEW (30 minutes)               Week of: ________
Trades: __   Total R: __   Win rate: __%   Avg win: __R   Avg loss: __R
Setups ranked by total R
1. ________   trades __   total R __   average R __
2. ________   trades __   total R __   average R __
3. ________   trades __   total R __   average R __
Rule breaks (followed plan? = no):   trades __   R lost __
Biggest leak this week: ________
One rule change for next week: ________
How I will check it next Sunday: ________

Trade review checklist

Every trade, at the close

Every week, at the review

What questions should you ask about every losing trade?

Ask the same questions in the same order every time, so a review cannot turn into guesswork or self-blame.

  1. Was this a setup from my written plan?
  2. Did I enter where the plan said, or early, or late?
  3. Was the stop where the setup said it should be?
  4. Did I leave the stop alone, or move it further away?
  5. Was the size my planned risk, 1R, and not more?
  6. What was my state at entry: calm, FOMO, revenge or hesitant?
  7. Would I take this trade again with the same information?

If every answer is right, the loss is the cost of the setup, not a mistake. Leave it alone and judge the setup on its total R over many trades. If any answer is wrong, it is a rule break, and it goes into Step 2 of the weekly review. A loss that came straight after another loss and broke the plan is worth a second look: our guide to how to stop revenge trading covers that pattern.

Should you review the trades you did not take?

Yes, briefly. A setup from your plan that you saw and skipped is part of the record too. If you only review the trades you took, hesitation never shows up as a cost.

How often should you review your trades?

Only a few trades a week? Keep the weekly review for the plan check, but judge setups on a month or more of trades, not one week. Four trades cannot tell a good setup from a lucky one.

Trading a prop challenge? Add the firm's limits to the weekly review: how much of your daily room you used, and how close you came to the floor. Our guide on how to pass a prop firm challenge has the routine.

What to do this week

What to do this week

Questions traders ask

How do you review your trades?

Check process before profit. After each session, give every trade its R result and a yes or no for followed plan. Once a week, rank your setups by total R, add up the R lost on trades where you broke the plan, and pick one rule to change.

How long should a weekly trade review take?

About 30 minutes if every trade already has its R result and a followed-plan answer. The daily review takes about 5 minutes. Most of the weekly time goes on ranking setups and costing rule breaks, not on reading charts.

What should a trade review template include?

For each trade: date, symbol, setup, entry, stop, exit, result in R, followed plan yes or no, a one-word mistake tag and one line of notes. For the week: total R by setup, R lost on rule breaks and one rule change for next week.

Should I review winning trades too?

Yes. A winner taken outside your plan is still a rule break, and it teaches you to repeat the break. Review winners for the same yes or no on the plan, and check whether you exited where the plan said.

What questions should I ask about a losing trade?

Was it a setup from my plan? Did I enter, place the stop and size the trade as planned? Did I leave the stop alone? What was my state at entry? Would I take it again with the same information? A loss with every answer right is the cost of the setup, not a mistake.

Sources and definitions

This page quotes no outside figures. The example week is made up to show the method. The terms it uses are defined in our glossary:

Educational, not financial advice.

RB Trading Pro Journal

Stop guessing. Start tracking.

30-day money-back guarantee · Cancel anytime · First 50 trades free

Find your edge →
Trade ReviewTrading JournalR-Multiple